Seeking the First Signs of Autism
Researchers Hope Early
Diagnosis, Intervention Can Improve Outcomes
|
|
 
Rebecca Landa of
Baltimore's Kennedy Krieger Institute tests
a child's responses to toys, looking for
clues that suggest early symptoms of autism.
(Marvin Joseph -- The
Washington Post)
|
|
By Suz Redfearn
Special to The Washington Post
Tuesday, April 15, 2003; Page HE01
While Winnie the Pooh and Tigger look down from the wall, a young
woman sits at a low table enthusiastically attempting to engage a
baby in play. She hands the child a bright orange block, then a
bucket for slam-dunking it. She initiates a round of peekaboo,
shielding herself behind her hands then suddenly revealing her
beaming face and sing-song voice. Next come the bubbles, then a
nifty plastic penguin.
It may seem like ordinary play, but it's serious business. Behind
the room's two-way mirror sits Rebecca Landa, director of the Center
for Autism and Related Disorders at Baltimore's Kennedy Krieger
Institute and associate professor of psychiatry at the Johns Hopkins
School of Medicine. From her hidden perch, Landa scrutinizes the
little one's reactions, gathering data for the first study funded by
the National Institutes of Health (NIH) to detect autism in children
aged 14 months and younger. Currently, autism usually isn't
diagnosed until around age 3, by which time some experts believe key
therapeutic windows have already closed.
And so when one little blond boy of 14 months on the other side
of the glass looks at the plastic penguin, takes it in his hands,
smiles with delight, looks into the eyes of the researcher, then
over at his mom, Landa notes that all appears to be on schedule with
his development.
But when a little dark-haired guy of the same age doesn't look at
the penguin or grab it, or look at anyone in the room to communicate
about the penguin, red flags go up in Landa's mind.
That's because, through the course of her six-year study, she has
found that many babies and toddlers with autism lack the
motor-planning skills to take hold of a new object and explore -- a
task that would be a cinch for a non-autistic child of that age.
Landa has also found that autistic babies aren't able to communicate
by expression about a topic like the penguin, or even react to a
simple game of peekaboo on a consistent basis.
Unfortunately, says Landa, these are subtle signs a parent may
not notice, simply thinking their child is distracted or obstinate.
And a hurried pediatrician may miss the signals, too, saying that
boys -- who are four times as likely to have autism as girls -- are
just slower to develop.
But the earliest signs of autism should become much better known
once Landa completes her work. She is soon to publish data showing
that many children who will later be diagnosed with autism are
showing subtle signs of the disorder as early as 6 months, an age
previous researchers had believed was too early to tell. By 14
months, her work shows, a constellation of signs has emerged in most
autistic children, making a definitive diagnosis possible.
"Such clear evidence of developmental disruption before babies
can be formally diagnosed," Landa said, "will be tremendously
helpful to doctors, therapists, teachers and parents."
Current tests for diagnosing autism can't be used for babies, as
the tests measure whether a child is making friends, whether he or
she has conversations in which there is reciprocation and whether he
or she engages in imaginary play.
Anatomy
of a Disease
So far, scientists have discovered no primary cause for autism,
but it is commonly attributed to abnormalities in brain structure or
function. Researchers are investigating possible genetic,
infectious, metabolic, immunologic and environmental links.
Autism is expressed differently in each person, but most have
problems with both verbal and nonverbal communication. Many cannot
hug a parent or conduct a conversation, and many will react badly to
changes in routine and engage in repetitive behaviors like flapping
hands. Most are unable to look others in the eye. Some with autism
can learn and hold jobs, while others require lifelong institutional
care.
The incidence of autism is 10 times what it was a decade ago, now
striking between two and six people per 1,000, according to the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). About 1 million
Americans are autistic today.
Why the spike? The National Association for Autism Research
(NAAR), a Princeton, N.J.-based parent group that funds autism
research, says the numbers may be attributable to better detection
and the fact that several autism-like disorders are now classified
under the umbrella term "autism spectrum disorder. Nevertheless, the
CDC is funding long-term surveillance studies to more closely
examine its incidence.
There is no quick screening procedure for autism; specialists
must spend time observing the child. And because there is no cure
for any of the autism spectrum disorders, the autism community has
placed much hope in early intervention. Many are excited about
Landa's study.
"Her work is contributing to a lower threshold for diagnosis.
It's groundbreaking," said Joe Guzzardo, spokesman for NAAR, which
funded Landa's research when it was in its pilot stage.
Jon Shestack, founder of Cure Autism Now (CAN), a Los
Angeles-based organization founded by parents to fund autism
research on neurobiology and early diagnosis, says even though
formal diagnosis doesn't take place until a child turns 3, people
with a very trained eye can now spot autism at 18 months. But that's
still not early enough.
"What's important about Rebecca Landa's work is that she's saying
you can do it a lot earlier than that," said Shestack.
Within the year, Landa plans to establish diagnostic guidelines
-- in writing and on video -- for pediatricians in the hopes that
they will begin proactively screening babies rather than waiting for
parents to come in voicing worries after their child has turned 3.
After that age, said Landa, critical time frames for effective
intervention may be quickly closing.
Acting
Early
Jennifer Haupt knows all about critical time frames. Haupt, a
resident of Clear Spring, Md., has two autistic children, both of
whom participated in Landa's research. The older, Ian, was first
diagnosed just before he turned 3. Subsequent intervention such as
speech and occupational therapy, as well as music, swimming and
horseback riding therapy didn't help him much. At 5, Ian isn't
speaking, and it has taken two years for him to learn to indicate
his needs and wants by showing his mother specific pictures.
But Zach, Haupt's second son, who was diagnosed at 18 months,
received immediate intervention and is now, at age 3, showing great
progress. He now has a vocabulary of about 10 words and can interact
well with others -- quite a feat for an autistic child of that age.
Haupt believes timing was key.
"When they're so young, they can be molded so much easier," said
Haupt, who quit her job as an accountant to care for her boys full
time when they were both diagnosed autistic.
Indeed, says Robert Beck, executive director of the
Bethesda-based Autism Society of America, if you can get to autistic
kids before they become isolated from their surroundings -- which
happens early -- you often can get them to communicate. Otherwise,
communication becomes extraordinarily hard.
Adds Carole Samango-Sprouse, director of neurodevelopment for the
Diagnostic Center for Young Children at George Washington
University, not every autistic child responds well to early
intervention, but about 75 percent do.
"When you get to the brain earlier, it's that much more plastic,"
said Samango-Sprouse. "You don't have to eliminate bad behavior
that's not there yet, but rather you can encourage good behavior.
The earlier you get there, the better the outcome."
According to Landa, there are certain "sensitive periods" of a
baby's life when the child becomes hyper-focused on understanding
specific elements in their environment. For instance, from birth to
about 12 weeks, a normally developing baby will be compelled to
focus on the faces of people around her, trying to understand what
faces are, what they convey. Between 6 and 12 months, babies
concentrate on language and speech perception, trying to understand
the subtle difference between similar sounds in an effort to get
ready to speak themselves, said Landa.
Her theory is if you get to autistic kids early in these
sensitive periods, you may be able to reroute confused brain signals
so that these sensitive periods are not squandered. Otherwise, says
Landa, bad signals from the disorganized portions of an autistic
child's brain are sent to otherwise strong brain tissue, where they
fall flat. The result is that the child may never come to understand
what faces convey or what words mean. But, says Landa, earlier
intervention can help.
"You have to go after a kid when he's doing things like
processing faces and breaking the speech stream down," said Landa.
"If you give them consistent input at those times, they start to get
it. If you wait until they're 3, you might miss out on shaping the
outcome most effectively."
Digging
In
Landa, a speech pathologist who has done autism research for 16
years, is wrapping up her early detection study this spring. Because
up to 10 percent of families who have an autistic child give birth
to another child with autism, Landa asked the parents of autistic
kids to enroll new babies. She has a control group of 50 kids and
another 50 in her at-risk group, constituting the largest sample
group of babies to be studied for autism since birth, said Landa.
Landa and her research team start by observing newborns in
maternity wards, checking to see if they prefer to stare at a
picture of a solid black stripe over a simple drawing of a face.
(The theory is that autistic babies will prefer the stripe).
When babies turn 3 months old, Landa or an assistant go to their
homes and present them with more stripe-or-face choices, this time
with the face drawings being more complex.
At 6 months the parents are asked to bring the babies in for
several hours of observed play. This is repeated at 14, 18, 24 and
36 months. At 3 years old, when the children can be diagnosed with
autism through traditional means, the study period ends.
Besides identifying developmental abnormalities in very young
autistic babies, the early detection study has allowed Landa to show
that some autistic kids will develop seemingly normally until about
14 months, at which point they regress. The National Institute of
Child Health and Human Development (NICHD) reports that about 20
percent of autistic kids may develop normally then regress
dramatically, but says its information on this phenomenon has been
based on anecdotal reports from parents. And, says NICHD, there is
little information about when this regression occurs. Landa's
research is likely to change that.
With the early detection study nearly done, Landa is beginning to
recruit 50 toddlers diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder for an
NIH-funded early intervention study. Kids will start the study
early, at 24 months, while most other autism intervention trials
begin at 36 months.
The study will focus on communication and social interaction,
blending multiple instruction methods like structured teaching and
following the child's lead, reinforcing positive behavior as they
go. The study will last five years, with researchers focusing on 10
kids per year. Landa's research team is looking for participants.
"What we're hoping to show is that if you intervene early enough,
you can help [autistic children] understand that they can do things
to make others understand them without having to cry," said Landa.
"They can use symbols, acquire a language and learn to engage with
you."
Part of the trial will involve examining the toddlers' blood.
This section of the study -- done by Karin Nelson (no relation to
Daniel Nelson, pictured above) and colleagues at the National
Institute of Neurological Diseases and Stroke -- could lead to
insights about possible pharmaceutical intervention for autism, said
Landa. It also opens new possibilities for developing early
diagnostic tests. The study will build on Nelson's previous findings
that autism and mental retardation can be seen in certain
over-expressed brain chemicals -- neuropeptides and neurotrophins.
Meantime, trials like Landa's are giving parents of autistic kids
hope. Nobody's talking about a cure, but with a condition as
devastating as autism, even the hint of an effective treatment is
exciting.
"If they can diagnose a child at 6 or 9 months," said Haupt, "who
knows what else they can do?"
Resources
More information on autism and autism research is available from:
National Association for Autism Research,
www.naar.org, 888-777-NAAR
Autism Society of America,
www.autism-society.org,
800-3AUTISM
Cure Autism Now,
www.cureautismnow.org, 888-8AUTISM
Organization for Autism Research,
www.researchautism.org,
703-351-5031
For information on free evaluations and early intervention
services, which every state is mandated to provide, call the
National Information Center for Children and Youth with Disabilities
at 800-695-0285.
For information about the upcoming early-intervention trial for
toddlers with autism, call 877-850-3372 or e-mail Rebecca Landa at
landa@kennedykrieger.org.
Suz Redfearn, a regular contributor to Health, last wrote
about hormone therapy.
© 2003 The Washington Post Company
|