Vaccination News Home Page                                            subscribe Vaccination NewsLetter

http://www.nytimes.com/2003/02/07/health/07SMAL.html?tntemail0

Many Balking at Vaccination for Smallpox

By DONALD G. McNEIL Jr.

resident Bush's plan to vaccinate 500,000 health care workers against smallpox is getting off to an unexpectedly slow start as hundreds of hospitals and thousands of nurses across the country say that they will not participate.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said today that only 687 volunteers in 16 states had been vaccinated since the program began two weeks ago, though it has shipped 250,000 doses of vaccine to 41 states.

Advertisement

A nationwide survey of state health officials by The New York Times this week found about 350 hospitals that declined to participate. Hundreds more have not yet decided.

The vaccination plan is part of the Bush administration's preparation against a terrorist attack or a war on Iraq, but the White House seemed unfazed by the slow start.

Scott McClellan, a White House spokesman, said the program was "still very much in the early stages."

"We are confident that more than enough health care workers will answer the call so that we are prepared to respond to protect our fellow Americans in the event of any attack," Mr. McClellan said.

Smallpox experts said they were surprised at the low turnout.

"Given the media attention, I thought people would be much more eager," said Elizabeth Fenn, a history professor at Duke University who has traced the disease's history. However, she said, health professionals might be more wary of the vaccine. When it was last used in the 1960's, it caused up to 52 life-threatening complications and two deaths for every million vaccinations.

No serious reactions have occurred among those vaccinated in the past two weeks, the disease centers said. Dr. William J. Bicknell, a smallpox expert at the Boston University School of Public Health who favors vaccinating 10 million people as quickly as possible, blamed the centers, saying the agency had let potential volunteers develop exaggerated fears, failed to assure them that they would be protected in case of bad reactions, and did not publicize the Israeli and United States military vaccination campaigns, which have had few problems.

On the other hand, Dr. Paul Offit, chief of infectious diseases at Children's Hospital of Philadelphia and a member of the president's advisory panel on smallpox vaccination, said he was "surprised," adding, "People are voting with their arms."

Dr. Offit was the only member of the panel to vote against nationwide vaccination, and his hospital was quick to back out because it had so many children with immune systems weakened by cancer treatment or organ transplants.

Public-health and hospital officials concede that they are struggling to find volunteers. Many health workers say they are skeptical that an attack is imminent and fear having a bad reaction to the vaccine or infecting a patient or relative with it.

Many also fear they will not be compensated, whether they lose a day's work to fever or end up near death from encephalitis.

A number of local health officers, charged with overseeing the vaccinations, said the vaccinations would sap already tight health budgets. They said the federal government had seriously understated the real cost of smallpox vaccinations, which require extensive training, screening and follow-up. "It's not like lining people up for flu shots at the mall," said Patrick M. Libbey, director of the National Association of City and County Health Officials, which has argued that the vaccinations cost $200 to $400 per person, while the disease centers have estimated it at as little as $13.

Sounding defensive in a telephone news conference yesterday, the centers director, Dr. Julie Gerberding, urged reporters not to concentrate on the low participation.

"Our goal is achievement of a preparedness capacity, not achievement of a number," Dr. Gerberding said. "We recognize that concerns about compensation are causing people to be slow to volunteer because they're afraid they'll fall through the cracks."

She declined to say how the issue would be addressed, and some said that could fuel the frustration of nurses associations that have called for the plan to be delayed.

"We have nurses calling us from all over the state with questions that we still don't have answers for," said Clair Jordan, executive director of the Texas Nurses Association, which has advised its 5,000 members not to volunteer.

Nurses unions in California, Massachusetts, Rhode Island and parts of Pennsylvania have also advised members not to volunteer.

Advertisement

"There's problems with protecting my family," said Linda Condon-McMahon, 43, an emergency-room nurse at Brockton Hospital in Massachusetts, "and protecting the patients till the site scabs over. Slapping a little bandage on it isn't going to protect them — somebody trips and falls, grabs your arm, and there goes your bandage."

Of the roughly 350 noncooperating hospitals found by The Times, 175 are in Texas, which, unlike most other states, last month pressed all of its 550 acute-care hospitals to make a decision.

The high refusal rate "is not surprising at all, nor is it important, as long as all of our communities will be adequately protected," said Dennis Perrotta, the Texas epidemiologist.

One of the first hospitals to balk was St. Vincent Infirmary Medical Center in Little Rock, Ark.

Margaret Preston, a spokeswoman for Catholic Health Initiatives of Erlanger, Ky., which owns St. Vincent's, said vaccinating workers "puts the patients at risk, and the risk outweighs the benefits."

Hospital chains have followed suit. The five-hospital Providence Health Systems in Washington State said it would not want vaccinated employees at work during the three weeks they could shed virus, and could not afford the resulting staff shortage.

In Richmond, Va., the Virginia Commonwealth University Health System said it would not vaccinate until one confirmed case of smallpox appeared in the world.

Dr. Richard Wenzel, the system's head of internal medicine, who treated smallpox decades ago in Bangladesh, called the decision "purely a medical risk-benefit assessment."

New Jersey has vaccinated the most so far — 97 health workers and police officers on Jan. 31.

The state's relative success is due to "very robust" communication with health workers, said Dr. Clifton R. Lacy, the state health commissioner. Also, he said, "New Jerseyans see themselves as somewhat vulnerable to bioterrorism. We were the epicenter for the anthrax event, and we still have post office buildings closed down."

Colorado vaccinated 19 people on Jan. 31 and planned to vaccinate 1,100 soon, said Dr. Ned Calogne, the state's chief medical officer.

Dr. Calogne was having his third smallpox vaccination, having had one as a child and one as a teenager going abroad.

Asked about the many volunteers backing out, he said with a laugh: "Maybe some are just waiting to see if the rest of us survive. I'm kidding, kidding."

Vaccination News Home Page

ALL INFORMATION, DATA, AND MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATION PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR LEGAL ADVICE.  THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.