This study will apparently
try to "judge effectiveness" of the live nasal FLUMIST vaccine in
schoolchildren, but is anyone tracking how many of the children who didn't get
the FLUMIST vaccine come down with flu symptoms because they got vaccine strain
flu from their recently vaccinated fellow classmates? This live virus vaccine
can produce flu symptoms in the vaccinated as well as transmit live vaccine
strain flu virus to others and be especially dangerous for those who are immune
compromised. Hopefully, there were no immune compromised children in the
classes that participated in this study.
They flinched and coughed,
fought back watery eyes and wiggled itchy noses.
But the children being
vaccinated for the flu yesterday at ElmerWolfeElementary School agreed that all of that was
worth it because of the one thing that was not in the room - a needle.
"It just felt a little
weird in my nose," said Michael Schaeffer, 7, still wriggling his nostrils
a few minutes after receiving the nasal spray vaccination. "But it felt
good 'cause it was like I wasn't having a shot."
Michael was one of the first
14 children nationwide to be vaccinated at school for the flu with two little
squirts to the nose.
He is part of a study
conducted by the University of Maryland's School of Medicine that will compare
absenteeism at Elmer Wolfe Elementary in UnionBridge during this winter's flu
season with absences at two other CarrollCounty elementary schools where
children have not received the nasal vaccination.
Researchers who administered
the nasal spray to the first batch of children yesterday will return to the
school several times over the next two months to finish the vaccinations.
The parents of about 130
Elmer Wolfe pupils have signed up to have their children vaccinated, and Dr.
James C. King Jr., a professor of pediatrics at the University of Maryland and
a pediatrician at the University of Maryland Medical Center, hopes to enroll at
least another 70 in his study.
The needle-free nasal
vaccine, called FluMist, was approved by Food and
Drug Administration this year for healthy people between the ages of 5 and 49.
This is the first flu season
the new immunization is available. Although children and adults can request FluMist from their doctors, Elmer Wolfe is the only school
in the country where children are receiving the new vaccination.
Michael, a second-grader, said
he was happy to participate in the study as long as it keeps him from becoming
as sick as he did two years ago when he last caught the flu.
"It made me really
sick," he said. "Sick enough to keep me away from school for a
day."
That wasn't so much of a
problem then, Michael said, because it was kindergarten, and he didn't like
kindergarten much. But now he's a second-grader, and that changes everything.
"It's just a matter of
the work," he explained. "I like that I can write a lot better, and
that makes the work much easier for me, so I don't want to miss school
now."
Asked what the nasal spray
does, Michael said, "I understand that it will help my body make more
antibodies for the winter and also help fight colds."
Others had a somewhat less
firm grasp of how the immunization works.
"It may be some kind of
poison thing, or it may be something that will work for us to stop the
flu," said 7-year-old Connor Carr. "I'm not really sure."
Connor said he had not
wanted to participate in the vaccination but that "my mom just threw me
into it."
Looking on during her son's
interview, Ann Carr laughed.
"That's not true,"
she told her son. "At first, you said you didn't want to do it. I said you
could get a shot instead. I give choices."
Connor rolled his eyes.
Researchers chose Elmer
Wolfe as their test school because parents there responded the most
enthusiastically to surveys distributed during the last two school years to
families at several elementary schools in Carroll and Howard counties.
Only children whose parents
have granted permission for them to participate in the study are receiving the
vaccinations at Elmer Wolfe.
The study covers the
$46-per-vaccination cost of the nasal mist.
The research team - they
call themselves the "Flu Crew" - recruited three Carroll County
doctors to help them pinpoint when this year's influenza officially hits the
area.
"We gave them flu kits
to diagnose the flu ,and we'll call them every
week," said King, the pediatrician conducting the study. "When it
hits, we'll know."
After the official start of
flu season is declared, researchers will distribute questionnaires to parents
of the vaccinated children, as well as to pupils at Westminster's Cranberry Station
Elementary and at Runnymede Elementary, located between Westminster and Taneytown.
Parents will be asked to
document how many times they take their children to the doctor and how many
missed school days and work days result from any winter illnesses.
Hoping to track the cost of
contracting the flu, researchers also will ask parents to keep track of how
much they spend on doctors visits, over-the-counter
medications and prescription drugs.
Meanwhile, school
administrators will track absences through a computer database at Elmer Wolfe
and the two "control group" schools.
Elmer Wolfe Principal Mary Stong said that as many as half her 472 pupils are absent
at any given time during flu season. Others come to school despite their runny
noses and sore throats, infecting classmates, teachers and parents, Stong said.
"It can run right
through our school," the principal said. "I'm really hoping this will
make a difference and we can keep our kids healthy this year."
One by one, oftentimes with
their mothers in tow, the youngsters received a quick squirt to each nostril,
sniffed (to make sure the liquid didn't drip out of their nose) and drank a
packaged fruit drink (meant to usher them quickly past the apparently bad smell
of the nasal spray).
Waiting for them after the
vaccination was a table of toys and sugary snacks.
Surveying the
classroom-turned-clinic, Dr. Elizabeth Ruff, a physician with the CarrollCounty health department, noticed
another distinct difference between yesterday's vaccinations and the hundreds
she's witnessed.
"There's no
screaming," she said. "I've never been in an immunization clinic
where there's no screaming and no crying."
=============================================
News@nvic.org is a free
service of the NationalVaccineInformationCenter and is supported through
membership donations.Learn more about
vaccines, diseases and how to protect your informed
DISCLAIMER: All
information, data, and material contained, presented, or provided here is for
general information purposes only and is not to be construed as reflecting the
knowledge or opinions of the publisher, and is not to be construed or intended
as providing medical or legal advice. The decision whether or not to vaccinate
is an important and complex issue and should be made by you, and you alone, in
consultation with your health care provider.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"