http://www.ias.org.nz/premvacc.htm
[Reprint (PDF) Version
of this article]
PEDIATRICS Vol. 101 No. 3 March 1998, p. e3
, §,
,
, and![]()
From the Departments of * Pediatrics,
Obstetrics
and Gynecology, and § Physiology and Biophysics, University of
Tennessee-Memphis, Memphis, Tennessee.
|
|
ABSTRACT |
|
|
Objective. We report our experience with routine
immunization of 89 premature infants in the neonatal intensive care unit
because 1) a substantial number of them developed abnormal clinical signs,
and 2) all but one of those who received diphtheria, tetanus, and
whole-cell pertussis (DTwP) vaccine responded with elevations of
interleukin-6 (IL-6) and C-reactive protein (CRP) concentrations that
are otherwise characteristic of bacterial disease.
Methodology. We hypothesized that the elevated IL-6 and
CRP levels were solely a response to immunization and that treatment with
antibiotics was not necessary. We performed this study in two consecutive
parts. In part 1, we prospectively evaluated 79 consecutive
premature infants who were immunized with DTwP, Haemophilus b
conjugate vaccine, hepatitis B vaccine, and inactivated polio vaccine,
(Hib, HBV, and IPV). IL-6 and CRP were determined before immunization
and every 12 hours on three occasions after immunization. In
part 2, we studied an additional 10 infants who received acellular
pertussis vaccine (DTaP) and who, 2 days later, received Hib, HBV,
and IPV immunization simultaneously. We followed the same schedule
of IL-6 and CRP determinations as in part 1.
Results. In part 1, 24 infants (30%) developed
abnormal cardiorespiratory signs within 24 hours after immunization. CRP
and IL-6 values rose to abnormal levels after immunization in all
but one infant; that infant was later shown to have a T-cell abnormality.
In part 2, 3 infants had abnormal cardiorespiratory signs after
simultaneous immunization with Hib, HBV, and IPV, but not after DTaP.
IL-6 and CRP levels remained normal in all 10 infants.
Conclusions. Part 1 demonstrates clearly the temporal
relationship between IL-6 and CRP increments after DTwP, Hib, HBV, and IPV
vaccines. In part 2 (DTaP was substituted for DTwP), there were
no elevations of IL-6 or CRP, thus indicating that whole-cell pertussis
component of DTwP was responsible for IL-6 and CRP elevations. Abnormal
cardiorespiratory signs occurred frequently after immunizations in
part 1, but they were unrelated to the magnitude of IL-6 and CRP
elevations. The frequency of cardiorespiratory difficulty and its
occasional severity suggest a need to monitor premature infants for
~48 hours after routine immunization.
Key words: immunization, C-reactive protein,
Interleukin-6, premature, bronchopulmonary dysplasia.
|
|
INTRODUCTION |
|
|
In 1982, the American Academy of Pediatrics recommended routine
immunization of premature or low birth weight infants at 2 months'
postnatal age.1 Later, a
survey showed that only 56% of pediatricians and 34% of family
physicians were in compliance with the American Academy of
Pediatrics recommendation.2 Some
cautiously used a vaccine dose smaller than recommended or arbitrarily
designated various weights at which immunizations were initiated.2 However, clinical trials have
shown that decreased doses of vaccine result in ineffective
immunologic responses to pertussis vaccine,4,5
and that the risk of neurologic signs was no higher in premature than
in full-term infants.4,5 Routine immunization of preterm
infants beginning at the second postnatal month is now a pervasive practice
in the physician's office and in the neonatal intensive care unit as
well. During the course of administering these routine immunizations,
we observed that a substantial number of premature infants developed
abnormal cardiorespiratory signs soon after immunization, often
necessitating evaluations for septicemia and therapy with
antibiotics. Blood culture results were regularly negative in these
infants, but our routine studies showed that C-reactive protein
(CRP) values were always elevated. Therefore, we prospectively
studied interleukin-6 (IL-6) and CRP responses to immunization,
seeking to demonstrate that immunization itself stimulates increases
in blood IL-6 and CRP levels, and that usually there is no need for
antibiotic therapy.
|
|
MATERIALS
AND METHODS |
|
|
The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of the University
of Tennessee, Memphis, and was performed at the Regional Medical
Center at Memphis from January 1996 to July 1997. Subjects for
this study were recruited from premature infants at ~2 months of
postnatal age who qualified for routine immunizations as
recommended.6 Infants with
acute illness or deteriorating conditions were not immunized.
Immunization was ordered by the attending physician after parental consent.
IL-6, CRP levels, and white blood cell (WBC) indices were determined
before immunization. If CRP values were normal and there was no
indication of an acute disorder, immunization was initiated. Within
12 hours after the immunization, IL-6, CRP, and WBC indices
were determined and then repeated three times at 12-hour intervals.
If CRP values were abnormal, IL-6, CRP, and WBC indices were
determined daily until all values returned to normal. IL-6 results
did not influence clinical decisions. Serum concentrations of CRP
were measured by rate immunonephelometry using automated
instrumentation (Automated Immunochemistry System, Beckman
Instruments Inc, Fullerton, CA). The level of detection was 0.4 mg/dL.
Plasma IL-6 was measured by a sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent
assay technique (Endogen Inc, Woburn, MA). The level of detection
was 1.0 pg/mL.
In part 1, we studied consecutively infants who received one set of
vaccines. A set of immunizations included diphtheria toxoid, tetanus
toxoid, pertussis vaccine adsorbed, plus Haemophilus b conjugate
vaccine (Tetramune, Lederle Laboratories, Wayne, NJ) and hepatitis B
vaccine (HBV) (Recombivax HB, Merck, Sharp & Dohme, West
Point, PA). Infants also received inactivated poliovirus vaccine
(IPOL, Connaught Laboratories Inc, Swiftwater, PA) unless they were
anticipated to be discharged within a few days.
In part 2, infants were consecutively added to the study, when
acellular pertussis vaccine was approved for primary immunization. Tripedia
(diphtheria-tetanus-acellular pertussis [DTaP], Connaught Laboratories)
was first administered to each infant. Two days later, HBV,
inactivated poliovirus vaccine (IPV), and Hib (Haemophilus b
conjugate vaccine) (HibTITER, Lederle Laboratories, Pearl River, NY)
were administered simultaneously. IL-6, CRP levels, and WBC indices
were determined before immunization as in part 1. Three determinations
of IL-6 and CRP were performed every 12 hours after Tripedia
and again after the immunizations that were given 2 days later.
As to method of administration of vaccine, diphtheria-tetanus-pertussis, Hib,
and HBV were given intramuscularly and IPV, subcutaneously, on the
anterolateral aspect of the left or right thigh using a 5/8-inch
long, 25-gauge needle.
All infants were monitored with pulse oximetry set to alarm
at < 85% O2 saturation, and with cardiorespiratory
monitors set at a respiratory pause
of > 20 seconds and a heart rate < 80 beats
per minute. Vital signs were documented by staff nurses. All infants
received acetaminophen, 10 mg/kg, orally before immunization, and
then every 6 hours for 24 hours after immunization. The
appropriateness of an evaluation for septicemia and for antibiotic
therapy was at the discretion of attending physicians. For analysis,
infants were placed in one of four groups based on the presence or
absence of abnormal cardiorespiratory signs 3 days before and
3 days after immunization. Group 1 consisted of infants
who had no abnormal signs either before or after immunization. Group
2 consisted of infants whose episodes began after immunization;
they needed intervention. Group 3 consisted of infants who had
occasional cardiorespiratory signs before immunization that
increased in frequency after immunization; this group also needed
intervention. Group 4 consisted of infants who had occasional
cardiorespiratory signs before immunization that were unchanged
afterward; this group did not need intervention.
Statistical Methods
Means, SD units, frequencies, and proportions were determined. Variables in
the four groups of infants were compared using both parametric and
nonparametric methods. Multivariate analysis of variance was used to
analyze continuous data such as birth weight, gestational age, and
highest CRP, followed by multiple comparisons using Tukey's method
if the F value was significant at P < .05. Because
of the wide variation in the postnatal age of the infants at
immunization, the data were analyzed using nonparametric method, the
Kruskal-Wallis test. Categorical data were compared among groups
using
2 analysis. A P
value of <.05 was considered statistically significant.
|
|
RESULTS |
|
|
In part 1, 79 premature infants received their first set of
immunization (diphtheria-tetanus-whole-cell pertussis [DTwP], Hib,
HBV, and IPV), and 2 infants received their second set of immunization.
Thirty-six infants received IPV, and the remaining infants were
given oral poliovirus vaccine at the time of discharge. Their mean
birth weight was 870 ± 270 g (490 to 2040 g);
63 infants (80%) were <1000 g. Mean gestational age was
28 ± 2 weeks (24 to 33 weeks). Of these infants,
77% were black and 39% were male. The mean postnatal age at the time
of first immunization was 72 ± 17 days (51 to
129 days). Mean weight at the time of immunization was
2050 ± 430 g (1180 to 3170 g). Postimmunization
determinations of IL-6, CRP, and WBC indices were made at means of
8 ± 3 hours, 19 ± 4 hours, and
32 ± 6 hours.
IL-6 was obtained in the first 30 infants. The mean preimmunization
value was 2 ± 2 pg/mL (1.0 to 6.0 pg/mL). Values
increased to a mean of 130 ± 90 pg/mL,
70 ± 70 pg/mL, and 15 ± 15 pg/mL, respectively,
at first, second, and third postimmunization determinations. Peak
IL-6 values appeared between 3 and 14 hours after immunization (Fig
1).
|
All infants in part 1 had preimmunization CRP values of
<1.0 mg/dL. After immunization, the first CRP was elevated (>1.0 mg/dL)
in 9 infants. The second CRP was elevated in 63 infants, and
the third was increased in 78 of the 79 infants. The first
abnormal CRP levels occurred at a mean of
20 ± 5 hours after immunization (11 to 34 hours),
with a mean value of 3.0 ± 1.5 mg/dL (1.5 to 9.5 mg/dL).
Peak CRP values (4.0 ± 2.0 mg/dL) occurred in samples collected
at a mean of 32 ± 9 hours (19 to 71 hours) after
immunization. In 25 infants, the highest CRP was 5.0 to
10.0 mg/dL. CRP values returned to normal (<1.0 mg/dL) at a
mean of 82 ± 27 hours (39 to 181 hours) after
immunization (Fig 1).
In part 1, 3 infants were extremely irritable and 24 infants
(30%) had abnormal cardiorespiratory signs that increased in frequency
or appeared for the first time. These signs included apnea,
bradycardia, and oxygen desaturation that required vigorous stimulation,
initiation, or increase in oxygen supplementation. One of these
infants required continuous positive airway pressure, and
2 others needed intermittent positive pressure ventilation. Cardiorespiratory
signs first appeared within 12 to 24 hours of immunization
and usually disappeared 48 hours later; however, in a few infants
the abnormal clinical signs persisted for 4 days. Two infants
received antibiotics; their blood cultures tested negative. Table 1 compares four groups of infants in part
1 based on the presence or absence of cardiorespiratory signs
during 3 days before and 3 days after immunization. The four
groups were significantly different as to postnatal age at
immunization. However, infants in groups 2 and 3 (those
who required intervention because of worsening symptoms or new
symptoms) were older than infants in group 4, in whom symptoms
were unchanged. There was no apparent relation between abnormal
clinical signs and the IL-6 and CRP responses.
|
Table 2 lists the clinical
characteristics of the four groups. A total of 74 infants had apnea of
prematurity, bronchopulmonary dysplasia (BPD), or both. Apnea of
prematurity was defined as a respiratory pause
20 seconds,
usually associated with heart rates <80 beats per minute, for
which no other cause could be identified.7 BPD was defined as a persistent
requirement for oxygen supplementation beyond 28 postnatal days
plus abnormal pulmonary radiographic findings.8 A total of 35 infants were
receiving medication for apnea of prematurity or BPD at the time of
immunization. Clinical characteristics were not significantly different
among groups.
|
In part 2, 10 infants were immunized. Their mean birth weight was
850 ± 300 (470 to 1370 g). Mean gestational age was
27 ± 2 weeks (24 to 32 weeks). Seven infants
were black, and 4 were male. The mean postnatal age at the time
of immunization was 62 ± 6 days (54 to 74 days);
mean weight was 1850 ± 550 g (1230 to 2640 g).
Two infants had occasional cardiorespiratory signs before immunization,
and these episodes were unchanged afterward. In 3 infants,
however, cardiorespiratory signs began or increased in frequency
after the simultaneous immunizations with Hib, HBV, and IPV. Each of
these infants required vigorous stimulation, initiation, or increase
in oxygen supplementation or bag/mask. IL-6 and CRP levels were not
elevated after any of the immunizations. Six infants had apnea of
prematurity; 8 infants had BPD. Two infants were receiving
theophylline, and 5 infants were on oxygen supplementation at
the time of immunization.
The only infant (in part 1) for which IL-6 and CRP levels did not increase
after immunization with DTwP was a 74-day-old white female in whom
truncus arteriosus was identified in utero. She was extremely
irritable after immunization. She had previously required six
evaluations for infection during her nursery stay, and in none were
IL-6 and CRP levels elevated; however, on separate occasions these
evaluations yielded blood cultures positive for Escherichia coli,
Staphylococcus aureus, and group D Enterococcus. At
5 months of age, results of an immunocompetence profile demonstrated reversal
of the CD4:CD8 ratio (0.26) and a decreased response to pokeweed
mitogen (<10% of control). Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)
culture and HIV-p24 antigen results were negative at 7 months
of age. Candida and cytomegalovirus infections were identified at
8 months of age, and the infant showed signs of rejection of a
surgical conduit that was placed for correction of her truncus
arteriosus. These findings are consistent with DiGeorge anomaly.
|
|
DISCUSSION |
|
|
This study of immunized premature infants revealed that 1) cardiorespiratory
symptoms occur in a substantial number (30%) of infants; 2)
immunization with whole-cell pertussis vaccine triggers production
of IL-6 and therefore CRP in virtually all infants; and 3) a lack of
CRP response after immunization (DTwP) occurred in only one infant,
in whom a T-cell deficiency was later demonstrated.
In part 1, a substantial number of our premature infants had
significant cardiorespiratory signs. Apneic episodes often required vigorous
stimulation; oxygen supplementation was enhanced, and occasionally
positive pressure ventilation was initiated. Cardiorespiratory signs
after immunization have been reported by others,9 but most of the
premature infants in our study had chronic lung disease, which may
have predisposed them to the abnormal clinical responses we
observed. Close monitoring for ~48 hours after immunization would be
advisable.6,10
Complications have been reported to occur more frequently after immunization
with DTP vaccine than with DT vaccine and are most likely caused by
the pertussis component.13
We used the whole-cell pertussis vaccine in our first
79 infants (part 1); 30% showed cardiorespiratory signs.
However, although there were no cardiorespiratory signs in
10 infants after they received the acellular form of pertussis
vaccine in part 2, there were moderately severe signs of
cardiorespiratory disturbance in 3 infants after immunizations
with Hib, HBV, and IPV together.
In part 1 of this study, the rise in IL-6 and CRP levels apparently was
stimulated by immunization with whole-cell pertussis (DTwP), because
such a response was not seen after the acellular form (DTaP) nor
after administration of the other vaccines 2 days later (part
2 of the study).
DTwP vaccines are prepared from inactivated Bordetella pertussis,
which includes multiple antigens. On the other hand, DTaP contains
several purified antigens, and the number of antigens varies
according to the manufacturer. DTaP (Tripedia) vaccine contains
inactivated toxoid and filamentous hemagglutinin, two of the five
purified antigens derived from B pertussis.14 Purified lipid A,
derived from B pertussis endotoxin, does not induce IL-1 responses
in human monocytes.15 Thus,
failure to stimulate IL-1 production may have resulted in absence of
IL-6 and CRP elevations.
CRP is one of the acute phase reactants produced by hepatocytes in response
to stimulation by cytokines,16
primarily IL-6. CRP is a reliable marker of bacterial sepsis.17 However, CRP also
increases after surgical interventions, in meconium aspiration pneumonitis,
and in necrotizing enterocolitis18,19 in infants without
sepsis. Abnormal CRP response to immunization as an incidental finding
has been reported.20 Our
study (part 1) is the first to demonstrate systematically IL-6 and
CRP increase after routine immunization with whole-cell pertussis
vaccine. With knowledge of the precise time of stimulation
(immunization) and without the influence of antibiotic therapy, we
could demonstrate timed responses and peaks of IL-6 and CRP. The lag
time for CRP response in rabbits after injection with E coli
lipopolysaccharide was 4 to 12 hours.21 As defined by the schedule of
blood collections, we observed a lag period of 12 to
29 hours. CRP increased in all but one infant; however, 69%
were asymptomatic. The incidence and severity of cardiorespiratory
signs were not related to the magnitude of IL-6 and CRP elevations.
In one infant, CRP rose to 10.0 mg/dL, yet there were no new
abnormal clinical signs after immunization. Two infants were treated
with antibiotics, and results of their blood cultures were negative.
In part 2, with total absence of abnormally high CRP and IL-6 values,
cardiorespiratory difficulties were apparent in three infants after
the Hib, HBV, and IPV set of immunizations.
We evaluated the IL-6 responses to immunization in the first 30 infants
(in part 1), and all 10 infants in part 2. IL-6 is an
important mediator of inflammatory response.22,23
It is synthesized and released by monocytes, macrophages,
lymphocytes, endothelial cells, fibroblasts, and many other cells.23 IL-6 acts as a
messenger between damaged tissues and hepatocytes; it is the major
inducer of acute phase protein synthesis, including CRP.16 In a study of adult volunteers,24 peak IL-6 plasma levels
were observed 2 to 4 hours after endotoxin injection, followed by
a peak CRP level at 20 hours. Within limits imposed by our sampling
schedule, we observed peak IL-6 responses at a mean of 8 ± 5 hours,
followed by peak CRP responses at 32 ± 8 hours after immunization.
In part 1, lack of CRP and IL-6 responses to immunization in one infant
may be significant. This infant was later found to have T-cell
deficiency (low CD4:CD8 ratio). An abnormal CD4:CD8 ratio is common
in AIDS patients. Children with symptomatic HIV infection usually do
not respond adequately to immunization.25
Their CRP responses are unknown. Immunocompromised patients with leukemia
(B-cell deficiency) who do not have T-cell deficiency respond
normally to tissue inflammation and generate CRP.26 Absence of a CRP response after
immunization (whole-cell pertussis) may be an easily demonstrated
sign of an underlying T-cell deficiency.
In conclusion, this study demonstrates that abnormal cardiorespiratory signs
occur in a substantial number of premature infants after routine
immunization, and that the frequency of abnormal clinical responses
and their occasional severity indicate a need for cardiorespiratory
monitoring for ~48 hours after administration of vaccine. For
infants already discharged, caretakers should be made aware of the
possibility of adverse reactions, either as a new symptom or
increasing episodes of symptoms. Also, they need to be advised to
contact the primary care physician immediately when these symptoms
occur.
Furthermore, unrelated to abnormal clinical signs, DTwP vaccine elicits elevated
IL-6 and CRP responses in virtually all infants studied. These
increases in IL-6 and CRP do not suggest septicemia; workup and
antibiotic therapy would not be indicated.
|
|
FOOTNOTES |
Received for publication Aug 5, 1997; accepted Nov 20, 1997.
Reprint requests to (M.P.) Newborn Center, 853 Jefferson Ave, Memphis,
TN 38163.
|
|
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
This research was supported in part by the Obstetrics and Gynecology Special
Education Fund.
We thank Rosalind Griffin and Marion Haynes for their editorial assistance,
Dr Henry Herrod for his critical review of the manuscript, and
Wenjian Yang for statistical analysis.
|
|
ABBREVIATIONS |
IL-6, interleukin-6. CRP, C-reactive protein. WBC, white blood cell. DTwP,
diphtheria-tetanus-whole-cell pertussis. HBV, hepatitis B vaccine. DTaP, diphtheria-tetanus-acellular
pertussis. IPV, inactivated poliovirus vaccine. Hib, Haemophilus influenzae conjugate
type b. BPD, bronchopulmonary dysplasia. HIV, human immunodeficiency virus.
|
|
REFERENCES |
|
|
Pediatrics (ISSN 0031 4005). Copyright
©1998 by the American Academy of Pediatrics
[Reprint
(PDF) Version of this article]