Jo Revill, health editor
Sunday December 22, 2002
The Observer
British children are suffering from an epidemic of behavioural problems,
with up to three pupils in every classroom affected by hyperactivity and
attention-deficit syndromes, The Observer can reveal.
The problem has become so acute that hundreds of thousands of children
are being prescribed a controversial drug, branded a 'chemical cosh' by
critics, that is so effective at calming troubled children that it reduces
them to a zombie-like state.
New figures obtained by The Observer show that the prevalence of
Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD) and the related Attention Deficit
Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) show that 345,000 children, or one in 20 aged
between six and 16, have the conditions.
The estimate is much higher than previously thought and is based on new
studies predicting that in a class of 30 children between one and three will
have the disorders, which causes uncontrollable and sometimes violent
behaviour.
The figures also show that the number of Ritalin prescriptions has soared
by 126 per cent over four years. In 1997 doctors were writing 921,000
prescriptions a year, but last year this rose to 2,085,000, at a cost of
£3.85 million to the NHS.
Ritalin, whose non-proprietary name is methyl-phenidate, is given to help
children to concentrate on schoolwork and calm down. Since its first
appearance it has been surrounded by controversy.
Opponents have accused the pharmaceutical industry of over-sedating
children and say that the amphetamine-like drug can act on the brain in the
same way cocaine does. However, many parents and psychiatrists say the drug
has been a lifeline, transforming the behaviour of children, allowing them
to get on at school and preventing the break-up of families.
There is also concern that some children may be prescribed the drug
without proper assessments, or without their treatments being reviewed
properly after being on the medication for a month or more.
Liberal Democrat MP Paul Burstow, who obtained the figures via written
questions to Health Minister Jacqui Smith, said: 'I am concerned that the
prevalence of these disorders seem to be on the rise. There is a very big
debate about the rights and wrongs of Ritalin, but we need to look at why
the prescription rates have gone up so steeply. It has become the option of
first choice for some families, but it needs to be given appropriately, and
only if it is really necessary.'
He added that there were still questions over the impli cations of giving
such a powerful drug to very young children. 'It is only now that Ministers
are beginning to quantify the problem. We need a coherent strategy so that
all the professionals involved with children - from teachers to social
workers to GPs and nurses - are alert to the signs and know what advice and
support to give to children and parents,' he said.
The behavioural problems associated with ADHD came to public attention
last week, when a couple who had adopted an 'uncontrollable and vicious' boy
won landmark damages from their local council for failing to tell them about
his problems. The boy's behaviour included attacking his pregnant adoptive
mother on holiday, putting her in hospital for several days. The court ruled
that Essex County Council should have given them a full and fair picture of
his history before adoption.