xmlns:v="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml"
xmlns:o="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:office"
xmlns:w="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:word"
xmlns="http://www.w3.org/TR/REC-html40">
A Military Secret No Longer
From the
Hartford Courant A Military Secret
No Longer Classified
U.S. Tests 30 Years Ago Exposed Thousands Of Sailors To Chemical And Biological
Weapons
By MARK
PAZNIOKAS And THOMAS D. WILLIAMS Courant Staff Writers Published
October 19, 2001
He kept the secret for 30 years. The former Navy skipper told no
one about the classified tests of Project Shad, how the Marine jets came
screaming out of the night off a remote Pacific atoll, spraying a 100-mile-long
aerosol cloud over his five tugboats. Then Jack Alderson's men started getting
sick.
"Some of the guys tried to go to the Pentagon or the American Legion and
said, `I did biological warfare testing.' They basically threw them out, told
them they were crazy," said Alderson, many of whose former crew complain
of chronic respiratory problems. "They told them, `We didn't do things
like that.'"
But now,
after seven years of inquiries from veterans, Congress and the Department of
Veterans Affairs, the Pentagon has confirmed that thousands of sailors were
present during a decadelong series of classified tests to determine the
vulnerability of U.S. warships to attack by chemical and biological warfare.
In a series of "fact sheets" given to veterans' hospitals and
organizations last month without wider public notice, the Pentagon acknowledged
that some of the tests involved spraying live biological weapons over U.S.
ships, including Alderson's tugs. Pentagon officials say that nerve agents such
as sarin and VX gas also were used, but they refuse to disclose where, when and
how.
Other tests involved exposure to "simulants," relatively harmless
microbes and chemical markers used as stand-ins for a potentially deadly
biological agent that resonates so powerfully today: anthrax. In all, more than
a dozen ships were used, in both the Pacific and Atlantic, from 1960 to 1970.
Involvement was brief for some ships and crews. For others, it was a full-time
assignment lasting years.
In the tests, Marine attack bombers sprayed either simulants or live biological
agents. Then the ships sailed through the resulting cloud and collected air
samples. In some tests, caged monkeys were placed on deck and later tested to
determine whether they had inhaled the material.
In the "hot tests," involving live biological warfare agents, the
sailors took shelter in compartments rigged with positive-pressure ventilation
designed to prevent the test material from infiltrating the ships. Other
precautions included inoculations for rabbit fever and Q fever, two of the
illnesses caused by the biological weapons employed, Pasteurella tularensis and
Coxiella burnetti.
"The crews who participated ... were not test subjects, but test
conductors," according to the fact sheets.
The Pentagon says no health problems have been linked to the tests, but the
veterans say no one has ever looked. A dozen test veterans reached by The
Courant in recent weeks, including a former medical services officer, say they
never were examined for exposure to the test material in the 1960s or monitored
in later years.
"I've had some concerns, respiratory problems like the others," said
Norman LaChapelle, the former medical officer. "You go to the VA, a good
physician will ask you, `What were you exposed to? What was your work?' Most of
us until now couldn't say."
One former tug skipper has cancer of the esophagus. Another officer died after
developing fibrous growths in his lungs. Dozens of others have varying degrees
of respiratory problems, Alderson and others said. One old skipper, who did not
want to be quoted by name, said that he collapsed and was critically ill for 18
days shortly after his Pacific service.
Ironically, the veterans say they are more concerned about the risks posed by
the powerful cleansing agents used to decontaminate their ships than they are
about the biological warfare agents. Some of the cleansing agents are now
suspected of causing cancer.
The recently released fact sheets detail only three series of tests, conducted
in 1963 and 1965 under the code names "Autumn Gold," "Shady
Grove" and "Copper Head." They are only a fraction of the tests
conducted as part of Shad, an acronym for "shipboard hazard and
defense."
The three fact sheets are three pages each. They represent nearly a year's work
searching archives and synthesizing records by a team led by Dee Dodson Morris,
a chemical weapons expert who holds a position meant to underscore the
Pentagon's new openness about chemical and biological warfare. Her title is
"director of lessons learned."
The post was created after Persian Gulf War veterans spent a frustrating decade
seeking information about chemical and biological weapons released by the
destruction of Iraqi munitions. The experience has left many doubting the
Pentagon's ability or willingness to fully investigate Project Shad.
Morris' fact sheets describe how the tests were supposed to be carried out.
Since her team interviewed no veterans, even though Alderson and others offered
to share their recollections, they do not claim to be a historical record of
what actually happened.
"The fact that the military is investigating, it doesn't breed confidence.
The military tends to downplay its involvement with radiation, with biological
warfare and chemical warfare," said U.S. Rep. Christopher Shays, R-4th
District. "The military does not have a very good record when it comes to
examining itself. Its past record of candid review, it's just not there."
Secrets And Seasickness
LaChapelle helped oversee Project Shad from the "mother ship," USS
Granville S. Hall. It was a converted Liberty ship with a mysterious past: In
the 1950s, rigged with remote-control steering, it was sent into the atomic
fallout from nuclear tests.
Years later, the Hall's crew members joked about setting off the radiation
alarms every time they sailed into Pearl Harbor.
"Every time we pulled into Pearl, it was as if we were a spook. We were
looked on as if we were orphans in the view of the `real Navy' or combat
Navy," LaChapelle said.
To test simulants, the Hall and the accompanying fleet of tugs sailed only 60
miles off the island of Oahu. For the hot tests, they traveled 800 miles to
Johnston Island, a remote atoll controlled by the Army's chemical warfare
program. It was a rough trip for the tugs. Designed for sheltered waters, they
pitched and rolled, as much as a stomach-churning 60 degrees.
"You had to be there to see it. Those tugs were just corks. There was no
way to get a good night's sleep on those things," LaChapelle said.
Even the rhesus monkeys got seasick.
"And a seasick monkey is a pissed-off monkey," Alderson said. The
8-pound creatures frequently escaped, climbing the radio mast. They practiced
their own form of biological warfare, defecating and urinating on the sailors
assigned to recapture them.
The tests almost always were done at night, when the air was calm. An A-4B
Skyhawk would take off from Johnston, afterburner roaring. Sometimes, the
sailors could see the cloud falling from the sky, settling over the decks of
the tugs.
When instruments showed that the cloud had dissipated, a crewman in a
protective suit would decontaminate, washing down the ship with seawater and
cleansers. The monkeys were sent to the Hall to be killed and autopsied - and
the results of those tests are still secret.
Secrecy was paramount, especially when the crews returned to Pearl. J.B. Stone,
a radioman assigned to the Hall in 1967 and 1968, said, "Guys who got
drunk and blathered in a bar in Honolulu would disappear," reassigned to
less-sensitive work.
The only tests known to take place in the Atlantic, "Copper Head,"
involved only simulated biological agents, according to the fact sheets. The
Navy provided a destroyer, the USS Power. Its crew was told nothing - only that
it was to steam from Florida to Newfoundland in January, one of its more
unpopular deployments.
"They wanted cold-weather testing. They got it. The winds were
horrible," said Larry Ginter of Fort Scott, Kan., then a petty officer. He
remembers a special crew that came aboard. "They told me they were testing
air currents and the air tightness of the ship."
Homer Tack Jr., a torpedo man from Butler, Pa., recalls conducting perhaps four
tests in January and February of 1965.
"We'd go to sea. The jets would fly overhead and spray. We'd get wet. We
all asked what went on. They said nothing," Tack said. He added, "I
told my family for 30 years that someday this was going to hit the news."
A Belated Disclosure
Alderson started asking the Pentagon in 1994 to open its files and provide
Veterans Affairs with enough data to evaluate what he and others believe is a
rash of chronic respiratory illness among veterans of Project Shad. He was no
crank. At the time, he was the chief executive officer of the marine district
that manages the port of Humboldt Bay, Calif. Even with the help of a
congressman, he got nowhere.
A book published in 1999, "The Biology of Doom," described some of
Project Shad. Then CBS News aired two stories about the secret tests in early
2000. Officials say that was the impetus for the disclosures about "Shady
Grove," "Autumn Gold" and "Copper Head."
Pat Eddington of the Vietnam Veterans of America said that his organization was
"appalled" the experiments were ever conducted and that it took 40
years for the Pentagon to acknowledge them.
But Alderson and some of the other veterans, while frustrated at the military's
slow response to their requests for information, said they are proud of their
service and defend the necessity of the testing.
"It was a highly motivated crew," said LaChapelle, now the
administrator of public health for Memphis and Shelby County, Tenn. "We
still feel like that. We were doing an important job for the Navy and the
Department of Defense."
He said he does not need to be reminded that biowar research was a real-world
concern during the Cold War - or now. Today, as a public health administrator,
he is in charge of investigating reports of anthrax terrorism.
ALL
INFORMATION, DATA, AND MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR
GENERAL INFORMATION PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE
KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED
AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR LEGAL ADVICE. THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO
VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU
ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"